If you are comparing local dining options in West Michigan, you might be looking at Flo’s vs Eddies Pizza Greenville MI to plan your next family dinner or game-day meal.
Quick answer: Flo’s Pizzeria in Greenville permanently closed on April 19, 2026, leaving Eddie’s of Greenville (Eddie’s Pizza Palace) as the premier local choice. While Flo’s gift cards remain valid at their Belmont, Rockford, and Grand Rapids locations, Eddie’s continues serving its highly rated crispy-crust pizza, smash burgers, and Mexican dishes at 609 N. Lafayette Street.
Key Takeaways
- Current Status: Flo’s Pizzeria Ristorante & Sports Bar in Greenville closed permanently on April 19, 2026.
- Eddie’s Legacy: Family-owned and operated since 1987, Eddie’s of Greenville remains fully operational under Head Chef and Owner Gary Templar.
- Menu Diversity: Eddie’s offers a unique menu combination of crispy-crust pizzas, smash burgers, and authentic Mexican cuisine.
- Gift Card Redemptions: Flo’s gift cards can still be redeemed at active sister locations in Belmont, Rockford, and Grand Rapids.
- Local Alternatives: Top active alternatives for dine-in pizza in Greenville include Mancino’s and B C Pizza.
Is Flo’s Pizzeria in Greenville, MI Still Open?
No, Flo’s Pizzeria Ristorante & Sports Bar in Greenville is permanently closed. The restaurant officially shut its doors on April 19, 2026, ending its decade-long run in the downtown area. While local online directories may still list the establishment as active, the physical location at 107 S. Lafayette St. is no longer in operation.
The Greenville location originally opened in May 2016 following an extensive $1.5 million building renovation. Founded by Sicilian-born brothers Daniele and Davide Uccello, the restaurant was a popular hub for Italian-American dining. According to ownership statements, the decision to close the Greenville branch was driven by post-COVID hospitality industry challenges and a desire by Davide Uccello to downsize operations to focus on his young family.
In contrast, Eddie’s of Greenville remains fully open and operational. Located at 609 N. Lafayette St., Eddie’s has been a family-owned and operated staple in Greenville for years. Under the leadership of Head Chef and Owner Gary Templar, our goal is to help create the best pizza Palace in Greenville Michigan by serving consistent comfort food that attracts consumers from all over West Michigan.
What is on the Menu at Eddie’s Pizza Palace in Greenville?
The menu at Eddie’s of Greenville features a highly distinct fusion of signature crispy-crust pizzas, fresh smash burgers, traditional Mexican cuisine, and a custom meal prep service. This diverse selection sets it apart from traditional Italian-only pizzerias. Visitors can enjoy everything from specialty pizzas to wet burritos under one roof.
For pizza lovers, the signature crispy thin crust is a major draw, with specialty options like the Chicken Bacon BBQ pizza leading in popularity. Eddie’s holds an impressive 4.3-star Google rating based on more than 780 reviews, as well as a 7.6 community rating on the Barstool One Bite App. Beyond pizza, the kitchen prepares authentic Mexican dishes including tacos, burritos, and fajitas, alongside thick, juicy smash burgers made to order.
As a long-standing casual American cuisine hub, Eddie’s also provides a dedicated custom meal prep service for local residents looking for healthy, ready-to-eat meals throughout the week. This combination of classic comfort food and modern convenience has secured Eddie’s position as a preferred destination for those seeking family friendly dine in pizzerias Greenville MI.
Where Can I Redeem Flo’s Pizzeria Gift Cards Now?
You can redeem outstanding Flo’s Pizzeria gift cards at any of the remaining active locations within the Flo’s Collection in West Michigan. Although the Greenville location has closed, the brand still operates three sister restaurants that fully honor all gift cards, loyalty rewards, and promotions.
To use your gift cards, you can visit any of the following active locations:
- Belmont: Flo’s Ristorante & Sports Bar, located at 5419 Northland Dr NE, Belmont, MI.
- Rockford: Flo’s Wood Fired Pizzeria, located at 125 E Bridge St NE, Rockford, MI.
- Grand Rapids: Flo’s Ristorante, located on Plainfield Ave, Grand Rapids, MI.
These active sister locations continue to serve the classic recipes that made the Flo’s Sports Bar Greenville Michigan menu famous, including their award-winning pizza sauces and traditional Sicilian-style entrees.
How Do Flo’s and Eddie’s Pizza Compare?
While Flo’s operated as a large-scale sports bar with a primary focus on traditional Italian-American fare, Eddie’s of Greenville offers a more intimate, family-oriented dining experience with a broader menu. The table below details the key differences between the historical offerings of Flo’s Greenville and the active operations of Eddie’s Pizza Palace.
| Feature | Flo’s Pizzeria (Greenville – Closed) | Eddie’s of Greenville (Active) |
|---|---|---|
| Status | Permanently Closed (April 19, 2026) | Fully Operational (Established 1987) |
| Address | 107 S. Lafayette St., Greenville, MI | 609 N. Lafayette St., Greenville, MI |
| Primary Culinary Style | Traditional Italian-American & Pizza | Pizza, Smash Burgers, & Mexican Cuisine |
| Key Ratings | N/A (Closed) | 4.3 Google Stars (780+ reviews) / 7.6 One Bite App |
| Special Services | Full Sports Bar, Catering | Custom Meal Prep, Family Dine-In, Carryout |
What Are the Best Alternative Dine-In Pizzerias in Greenville, MI?
The best active alternative dine-in pizzerias and sports bars in Greenville, MI include Mancino’s and B C Pizza. These local staples offer excellent sit-down dining, reliable service, and deep roots in the West Michigan community.
Mancino’s is highly regarded for its oven-baked grinders and classic pizzas, making it a reliable spot for casual lunches and dinners. B C Pizza is widely recognized for its family-friendly buffet options and specialty specialty pies. Both locations serve as excellent choices for those searching for the best sports bars with pizza in Greenville MI or Greenville MI restaurants with outdoor seating during the warmer months.
If you are looking for where to watch the game and eat pizza in Greenville, these active establishments provide comfortable seating, multiple television screens, and a welcoming atmosphere for sports fans and families alike.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Flo’s Pizzeria in Greenville, MI permanently closed?
Yes, Flo’s Pizzeria in Greenville permanently closed its doors on April 19, 2026, due to post-COVID industry challenges and the owner’s decision to downsize operations.
Where is Eddie’s of Greenville located?
Eddie’s of Greenville is located at 609 N. Lafayette St., Greenville, MI 48838. It has been operating at this location since 1987.
What are the active locations for Flo’s Pizzeria?
The active locations for Flo’s Pizzeria are in Belmont (Ristorante & Sports Bar), Rockford (Wood Fired Pizzeria), and Grand Rapids (Plainfield Ave).
Does Eddie’s of Greenville serve food other than pizza?
Yes, in addition to signature pizzas, Eddie’s of Greenville serves smash burgers, a complete Mexican menu (including tacos, burritos, and fajitas), and offers a custom meal prep service.
What is the Google rating for Eddie’s Pizza in Greenville?
Eddie’s of Greenville holds a 4.3-star rating on Google with over 780 reviews, as well as a 7.6 community rating on the Barstool One Bite App.